Doomed / Chuck Palahniuk

Doomed
(follows Damned)
by Chuck Palahniuk

fantasy

copyright 2013
opened / abandoned in December 2015

rated 3/10: so bad it's embarrassing

Sometimes an author writes a book for a particular demographic. People outside that demographic read the book and think, Wow! that's an interesting insight into something that would normally not interest me !

Palahniuk has not done that.

He has written a book which -- as far as I can guess -- is aimed at a very specific audience. If you are outside that target demographic -- the book is trash, rubbish and awful.

Absolutely cringe-worthy. I stopped reading at page 29.

I'm pleased to say that I am definitely not amongst the people who enjoy the Doomed style of crudity and nastiness.

Osiris / EJ Swift

Osiris
(Osiris Project #1)
by EJ Swift

science fiction

copyright 2012
read in December 2015

rated 5/10: readable, but only if there's nothing else

An interesting concept: One self-sufficient city survives the environmental destruction of the Earth. There are the haves... and the have-nots. The haves built the city. The have-nots arrived later, as refugees.

Hang on ! Haven't I read this before ?

Oh yes, a recent movie. Which I believe was set in a spaceship. Or, perhaps, set in a train. Oh yes, and lots of other dystopian science fiction stories. It's not a new idea. No worries, the Osiris world is interesting enough. With the bonus question of, Is there any other livable area anywhere else on Earth ?

So I'm reading. And it's not gripping. Family conflict, political manoeuvrings, rich girl introduced to suffering of poor people, betrayal, love... It's all there. Yet it simply fails to interest me. With all that's happening, I feel that nothing much is really happening.

The more I read, the less interest I find. Conflict appears -- then fades away. It all seems to be rather unbelievable... rather unreal.

About two thirds of the way through -- I give up, and read just the last few chapters.

There are two main characters, they have alternate chapters. That works well, no confusion as we read the two views of the story.

In the last few chapters... But wait ! I'm going to write a spoiler. So first: This book is that most annoying of books, the introduction to a series. There is no conclusion, no wrap-up, no sign of a satisfying ending. Not a "novel", just an extended "chapter one".

And this is the spoiler, for those who want to read this book: In the last few chapters, a missing third character is really dead, one main character gives his life to save the other but reappears, alive, in the next chapter, the other main character is missing presumed dead but living under a false name. Ho hum.

I skipped over 140 pages. In that 140 pages, all I apparently missed was confirmation that this is book one of many. There is no conclusion, no plot closure. Just an introduction to many more books which are threatened for the future.

Definitely not a novel. More an investment for the future income of the author. If there are enough readers willing to risk the boredom of subsequent books in the series.

===

21mar18:

It doesn't take me long to realise that it is familiar. I've barely finished chapter one before I realise, This book is not worth reading. I stop reading and wonder, What did I think of it the first time?

I read my five-year-old review, reinforced my decision to stop reading.

One plus, though: I notice that the cover does say, clearly, "Book One". It's the ones that hide the "to be continued" that really annoy me.

Down to the Earth / Robert Silverberg

Down to the Earth
by Robert Silverberg

science fiction

copyright 1969
read in December 2015

rated 6/10: read to pass the time

As I start reading I think, Ho hum, another sadly dated book from the golden years of science fiction. Then it improves. We move into the alien jungle and it's timelessly imaginative. Then the ending is... weak.

In a more modern introduction, Silverberg says that he did not think that Down to Earth was a particularly good book. Now, apparently, he has changed his mind. I didn't read all of the introduction, I didn't want to spoil the story. Perhaps the author's opinion of his book was improved when a publisher wanted to reprint it ?

Anyway...

Some bits are, indeed, strongly influenced by attitudes of the 1960s ! We are introduced to eight tourists. There's the tinker, the tailor, the soldier, the sailor... Hang on ! That's only four !? Because there are also four wives. And they are no more than, the wives. Goodness ! Let's see a modern author get away with that level of sex-based typecasting !

Then the hero reaches the jungle. The jungle, the locals, the flora and fauna are timeless. Somewhat ridiculous, perhaps, but timeless science fiction imagination.

The ending, however, is a little disappointing.

Half of the ending -- the physical aspects -- are largely unsurprising. I can see it coming, no great surprise. The mental -- or perhaps spiritual -- ending is... ridiculous.

Aliens who can bring us to nirvana ? Good grief. Magical mind powers which will bring peace and harmony to all who are ready for it ? That's a bit sudden, isn't it ?! Overtones of religious ecstasy brought on by mystic jungle portions ? Not without some reasonable justification, thanks very much.

It's not a bad book. Interesting, readable, a well constructed plot.

It just needs a bit more logic to support the wilder aspects of the plot finale.

====

"Why should I have to work for everything ?! It's like saying I don't deserve it !"... Calvin per Watterson

   

Words of Radiance / Brandon Sanderson

Words of Radiance
(Stormlight Archive #2)
by Brandon Sanderson

fantasy

copyright 2014
read in December 2015

rated 7/10: well worth reading

What a lot of fun ! What a unique -- yet acceptable -- world ! What nice characters :-)

This is "book two" and I'm guessing that the hero is continuing his adventures but the heroine is new to this book. It did take me a while to decide that the heroine is "new". Then the occasional flashbacks reached a conclusion and I thought, Aha ! Very satisfactory !

It's action and adventure all the way. There are battles fought, with thousands killed... Yet very few named characters are at risk. And I like that.

The main characters are likeable. They battle their inner demons and overcome the traumas of past suffering. But the past is past, either in short flashbacks or in book one. (I wonder if book one was as gloomy as the heroes memories of it !?)

Nearly everyone is pleasant, good humoured, dependable. The villains are sneaky, their motives are acceptable, they are dealt with... adequately. Enough villains survive to make book three an interesting continuation of the story.

There is, however, a problem with that feeling that the story will continue:

The heroic ending would be deus ex machina -- if it had not been so clearly signposted ! Hero and heroine make huge steps on their path to super-being-dom. (You know, on their path to being super-beings.) Battles are won, secret troves found, all looks good. But...

There is still a feeling of incompleteness.

Amazing battles. Incredible discoveries. Thunder and lightning and the whole meteorological works. Yet it still feels a little, So what ?!

That's the problem with a continuing saga. There's a need to wrap up one adventure -- but leave enough for the next books. I just wanted a little more wrapping up.

Still, not a problem ! This book is complete, it can be read -- and enjoyed -- by itself. But I think it would be even better if I read all of books one to... N... one after the other. The adventure is great. The continuity (assuming it does, eventually, reach a solid conclusion) would be even better.

The world itself -- the people, the geography, the magic... but I really mean the flora and fauna -- is fascinating. A terrifically imaginative effort by the author.

I enjoyed the book. I think I would enjoy the complete saga, even more.

====

"Why should I have to work for everything ?! It's like saying I don't deserve it !"... Calvin per Watterson

   

Wonder / Robert J. Sawyer

Wonder
(WWW #3)
by Robert J. Sawyer

science fiction, subadult

copyright 2011
read in December 2015

rated 6/10: read to pass the time

This book is light, packed with interesting ideas, and very Enid Blyton.

Enid Blyton wrote for children. Some of the stories -- especially the short stories -- have a moral, a message... a lesson. Sawyer has written for tweens and teens. And Wonder contains several morals and messages.

Some of the messages fit firmly within the story. Equality of all creatures including conscious artificial intelligences, for example. First teen sex though... Yes, the teen heroine has her first sex. But her mother's pre-sex discussion goes beyond plot into preaching.

There's a lot of that preaching in the book. Love and respect one another, people power, freedom for all... It's all very positive, all in the spirit of good triumphing over -- and converting -- evil. All a bit overly optimistic, but I'm always in favour of over-optimism, it's much better than unrelenting gloom :-)

It's all a lot of fun ! Nice people, enormous possibilities with AI, excitement with no real threat. Plus important issues discussed -- or at least presented -- to open the reader's mind.

Enjoyable, readable, mostly harmless.

====
Einstein's Theory of Intelligence: "It's very easy to be smart. Just think of something really dumb to say, then say the exact opposite." … per Pardon my Planet
   

Lock In / John Scalzi

Lock In
by John Scalzi

science fiction, young adult

copyright 2014
read in December 2015

rated 9/10: really, really good

Sometimes I finish reading a book and immediately think, I'd like to read that again ! This is one of those books. And the second reading was even more enjoyable than the first.

The introductory explanation to "Haden's Syndrome". (That's the cause of the book's "lock in" situation.) It's an article from HighSchoolCheatSheet.com... Brilliant !

There are the occasional lines like that, that generate a spontaneous chuckle. There are clever lines, poking gentle fun at some clichéd foibles of our world. In general, though, this is a book of action and adventure. A not-so-standard police story.

It's near-future science fiction. And a major part of my enjoyment is, it's a very positive view of the near future. Well, okay, millions of people have been paralysed by an epidemic, now endemic, of Haden's syndrome. But they are getting on with life, developing supporting technology, working towards a better life for all...

Except, of course, for the villains. For them it's business as usual: ruthless. Now extending their predatory business practices into murder and social mayhem. Yet the villains are rather amateurish at this criminal extension to their business... Which makes it a bit easier for the hero to turn the tables.

Overall, the plot is straightforward. Plenty of clever discovery but no sudden changes of direction. Thank goodness... The excitement is more real than contrived.

The characters are also very likeable -- friendly, supportive, cheerful. Except for the villains, of course. Though even they are realistically amoral... I've worked with several managers who would support the same general concept that, "business is business" and personal ethics are irrelevant.

In fact, the characters are so nice, the technology so clever, the good heroes so very good and the clever heroes so very clever -- it's a bit of a utopia. The future through rose-tinted glasses. The cynic in me says, yeah, right, as if :-( The reader in me says, yeah, great, love it !

Which brings me to the "young adult" categorisation...

This book is for the young adult reader. Those who still believe that good will defeat evil, that good friends will be loyal and helpful and kind. That the police will bring all perps to a balanced and fair justice. That murder will happen but let's not dwell on the pain and suffering and blood.

Better yet: the heroes care because it's murder.

Inspector Rex is like that: the police solve crimes because they believe that crime is wrong. American cop shows -- and plenty of crime novels -- seem to believe that a murder is only serious if a relative (of the crime fighter) is involved. The Lock In hero (and associates) solve crimes simply because crime is wrong. Good on them !

And...

This book is also good for the older cynic, who simply hopes that the world will be that positive. And who likes to read a book which reflects the possibility that all will turn out okay in the end.

Oh, Lock In is also an exciting, clever and occasionally funny book. Which I thoroughly enjoyed reading. And then thoroughly enjoyed -- and better understood -- when I immediately read it a second time.

Good fun, good science fiction, a very enjoyable novel.

====
Einstein's Theory of Intelligence: "It's very easy to be smart. Just think of something really dumb to say, then say the exact opposite." … per Pardon my Planet
   

The Explorer / James Smythe

The Explorer
by James Smythe

science fiction ?!

copyright 2012
read in December 2015

rated 5/10: readable, but only if there's nothing else

Here the deep and significant question: It it possible to set a story in a spaceship and the story is *not* science fiction ? James Smythe does his best.

There's a spaceship. There's a time loop, astronauts, an "anomaly" in space... All this has very little to do with the story. I *think* it's a study of people acting in a stressful situation. They may as well be on a boat.

In fact, I suspect that the author would have trouble distinguishing a spaceship from a boat. The science is not bad. It's embarrassing.

The ship's engine is going continuously -- yet there is no trace of "gravity", no drift against acceleration. After weeks of acceleration the engine is stopped. Just a quick squirt of the forward thrusters -- and the ship stops moving ! There is battery-powered artificial gravity -- but it only works when the ship is "stopped".

There's a viewing bubble which allows 360 degree viewing. Sometimes the view is like the view from a garden on Earth... but half the time, space is entirely black.

In order to go as far as possible, fuel has been developed to give maximum thrust from minimum volume of fuel... Then the ship is built with storage rooms that are almost empty, holding spare stocks of items which are rarely used. The chief protagonist is able to sleep in a room which contains just a few crates of supplies. The whole ship is biiiig, and spacioooooous. And the crew spend almost all of their time in one room at the front.

So the science is rubbish. That's distracting, but not a serious problem.

I read the first chapter or so and think, everyone's dying, this'll be a short book. Then we hit the time loop and I think, this is boring, makes it seem like a very long book. Then I accept that it's not science fiction, it's a character study, and I think, this is still boring but I want to find out how it ends.

Then the protagonist escapes the time loop and I think, no he can't, to do that he must be in the time loop so if he has just escaped from the time loop then he's not in the time loop so he can't escape from it... And the story ends. With no further explanation. Because the characters have been studied and that's that. It's not as if it's science fiction, is it.

Having written that last paragraph I went back and revised my rating, from six to five.

There are interesting ideas in this book. The commercialisation of space flight. Reasons and expectations of crew and sponsors. The gradual explanation of the deaths of various crew members.

It's a character study set in a spaceship. I reach the end of the book and think, interesting characters, though overall depressing. Okay, I suppose, if all you want is a book which analyses the characters.

Science fiction is supposed to be, What if ? This book is more, So what.

====
"A city without trees is not fit for a dog"... per Ginger Meggs